From TikTok to Rednote: The Dialectical Transition into Opposites

In just a few days, thousands of American TikTok refugees flocked to China’s Rednote. What began as retaliation against the U.S. TikTok ban soon turned into a comparison of living expenses, with all the lies America spread about China building up, ready to "backfire" at any moment.

January 16, 2025
author_image
Cuban American philosophy instructor at Southern Illinois University. Director of the Midwestern Marx Institute
Click Register
Register
Try Premium Member
for Free with a 7-Day Trial
Click Register
Register
Try Premium Member for Free with a 7-Day Trial

The last week has shocked American lawmakers as their efforts to ban the Singaporean app, TikTok, under the auspices of being used by the Chinese to surveil Americans, has backfired terribly.

Millions of Americans marched to the App Store this week to download the Chinese equivalent of Instagram, Rednote, which translates to Little Red Book, an homage to the famous cultural revolution pocketbook of Chairman Mao’s Quotations.

The iOS version of Xiaohongshu saw over 240,000 downloads in a single day in the U.S. and has reached the top of the overall free iPhone app charts in more than 70 countries and regions, including the U.S., Antigua and Barbuda, Bermuda, Iceland, Switzerland, and the UK.

Is this not a clear case of a process turning a thing into its opposite, as the monumental German philosopher G. W. F. Hegel repeatedly describes it in the various moments of the Concept’s development in his Logic?

The American political class, unable to tame the contradictions of its decaying society, is forced to externalize onto a boogeyman ‘other’ the faults for the wretched conditions its system has put its people in. China is today’s boogeyman, the entity onto which all blame is placed.

It is not the U.S.’s decades long covert involvement in the drug trade, used to fund the contras and destroy poor communities at home, which has led to the fentanyl crisis of today. No, according to the fanciful imagination of the ideologues of empire, it is the Chinese who are to blame!

It is not the fault of massive monopolistic investment firms like Blackrock, Vanguard, and State Street for buying up property and farmland for speculation. No, it is the Chinese! You know, the country whose president quite literally emphasized that ‘houses are for living in, not for speculation,’ which is leading the speculation effort in the American housing market.

American propagandists turn the world on its head as a way to cope with the fact that it is the decaying, highly financialized capitalist system that has produced these outcomes for the people, not a foreign boogeyman.

The war on TikTok is but one part of an all-out assault on China by the American ruling class.

Image created by Chinese Weibo blogger @青红造了个白.

The irrationality of this attack could not be any clearer once one realizes that TikTok in the U.S. was forced to hand control over its servers from ByteDance to Oracle, a Texas-based company that quickly hired a litany of NATO and state department officials to do ‘content moderation’ on the app: a code word for censoring discourse that challenges their narratives, and proliferating those which defend it.

Our accounts at the Midwestern Marx Institute, the largest Marxist-Leninist think tank in the U.S. would get banned seven times, including our first account which amassed nearly half a million followers in less than a year.

But even with all the censorship on the American version of the app, this was not enough. Their control was tubular, and leakages to their censorship edifice became evident.

Videos showing the truth about key geopolitical events, especially the barbarity of the Zionist entity’s genocidal assault on Gaza, would continue to go viral, reaching millions of Americans. Such a disavowal of the ‘official narratives’ of the U.S. empire could not go unpunished. Banning the app completely was the only ‘solution’ the elite could come up with.

These are the actions of a desperate empire in the midst of a deep crisis of legitimacy.

As could have been expected, the intent to censor the truth by banning TikTok turned into its opposite, into the great migration onto the Little Red Book app by millions of American ‘refugees.’

Videos are now going viral of American creators saying quite explicitly that they will rather give their data to Xi Jinping than the U.S. government. The propaganda, clearly, is no longer working on a population struggling with paying bills and drowning in debt.

The development of the crisis of capitalism has turned the American dream into its opposite, into the American nightmare. This is an era of nodal points, where radical leaps into opposites are evident all over.

The TikTok ban is a clear case of an action whose intended result produces an opposite effect.

The hope to curb ‘Chinese surveillance of Americans’ on a Singaporean app backfired into a mass exodus to a Chinese app.

As we say in Cuba, le salió el tiro por la culata.

Editor: Zhongxiaowen

VIEWS BY

author_image
Cuban American philosophy instructor at Southern Illinois University. Director of the Midwestern Marx Institute
Share This Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Comment
Cancel

  1. Haha lol. TikTok refuges have woken up en mass to their govt lies

    Show more
    Show less
    likednot_liked 2likednot_liked 0Reply
  2. R

    Viva RedNote! The truth will set you fleeing! 🧧

    Show more
    Show less
    likednot_liked 1likednot_liked 0Reply
  3. Very professional article, it is a reality and this is what is happening with everything in the Western world, as their lies collapse.

    Show more
    Show less
    likednot_liked 1likednot_liked 0Reply
  4. A

    Hope lies with the youth here in the US. We are waking up from the false narratives foisted upon us

    Show more
    Show less
    likednot_liked 0likednot_liked 0Reply